Winnipeg, Canada Subscribe
Another feminist response to pop culture Learn More

How true crime podcasts exploit the grief of women of color

True crime turns violence into a repeatable commercial format. Hosts promise proximity to a murder, disappearance or long-hidden abuse, then convert unease into episodes, advertising breaks and recommendations for similar stories. It can inform, yet it can also monetise trauma, especially when a dead woman is racialised as a warning about a neighbourhood, family or migrant community.

For Australian listeners, the format arrives through a crowded local market. ABC and SBS programming sits alongside commercial radio networks and independent producers, while Spotify and Apple Podcasts display Australian rankings that can amplify emotionally forceful shows. Commutes on Sydney and Melbourne trains can make the format feel intimate: headphones on, a case unresolved, another episode queued.

The feminist question is not whether true crime should exist. It is who receives narrative authority, whose grief feels legible and whose pain is sold as atmosphere. Women of colour often receive less individual history than white women, even when they occupy an episode’s emotional centre.

Calling out that pattern does not make victims or communities interchangeable. Race, class, sexuality, migration and colonial power intersect differently. Ethical criticism must name those systems without turning a woman into a racial type or presenting listeners as consumers of packaged tragedy.

Grief as a commercial engine

Commercial true crime relies on unequal attention. A white woman in a brief montage may be remembered by her name, family photographs and imagined future. A Black, Asian or Indigenous woman is more often introduced through a label: “addict”, “prostitute”, “gang associate” or “the wrong crowd”. Such terms flatten biography into a shortcut and turn racial difference into the sales pitch.

Grief also performs labour. A host invites listeners to feel implicated, then uses that emotion as a bridge to subscriptions, merchandise or live events. Performative grief can overshadow remembrance: learning a name, tracing institutional failure and supporting survivors.

Racialised scripts and manufactured identities

True crime narration often borrows older cultural scripts. The Asian sex worker becomes a hidden victim, the Latina sweetheart a supposed secret, and the Indigenous woman a casualty of neglect. These roles may contain fragments of truth, but repetition makes them feel like evidence. Sensationalism masquerades as analysis, using race to explain character instead of context.

Australian listeners encounter a further complication. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women are not simply another racial minority; their vulnerability is shaped by sovereignty, colonisation, state removal and policing. Flattening those distinctions into “drug-affected” or “high-risk” stories reproduces the stigma that keeps some women invisible.

Colonial aftermath in the Australian frame

Public discussion cannot ignore the Royal Commission into Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Deaths in Custody, which delivered its final report in Canberra in 2017 after hearing evidence from families and experts. Its subject was custody, not podcasting, but it exposed systemic harm against Indigenous people and the grief relatives carry when public debate compresses it.

Many Aboriginal communities observe Sorry ceremonies and hold community memorials, forms of collective mourning that resist the individualised “whodunit” frame. A podcast can acknowledge this without making a personal tragedy a public listening experience. Editorial humility requires local knowledge, transparent sourcing and care about what a story asks communities to carry again.

A hierarchy of victimhood

White women are frequently granted the status of emotionally legible victims. Their parents, partners and friends explain contradictions in their lives; their choices are treated as meaningful. Women of colour are more likely to have their characters explained through stereotypes, criminal networks or supposed cultural values. This hierarchy grants innocence, interiority and public sympathy in unequal doses.

The Sydney “Black Widow” case shows how a local story enters an inherited racial script. Chinese-Australian businesswoman Ru Ying Leng was murdered, and the sensational label attached to her husband drew on the stereotype of an Asian woman as a cold, calculating murderer. The case differed from the histories of Black women in American crime media, yet it shows how a real death can confirm a prefabricated fantasy.

Listening habits and the Australian market

Podcasting makes intimacy unusually portable. A listener may hear a grieving relative between a sponsor’s mattress advert and a teaser for another murder. Hosts can correct misinformation in real time, but speed also rewards shock, speculation and moral certainty. The pause that might complicate a stereotype is often cut for pacing.

Australian audiences navigate this through public-service broadcasters, commercial networks and independent shows competing for attention on Spotify and Apple Podcasts. Material is abundant; editorial space for context, survivor consent and accountability is scarcer. Ethical production may look less viral, with clearer corrections, diverse expertise, fair payment and consequences for stories that exploit the people they centre.

A listener’s guide to ethical crime audio

Useful criticism begins with the episode’s framing, not with a listener’s appetite for gore. Questions for reviewers include:

A stronger production record should make several promises visible:

None of these practices removes the ethical problems of making crime profitable. They can shift the emphasis from emotional consumption towards explanation, accountability and the rights of people whose grief made a story marketable.

Listen with care and demand better accountability

Support feminist criticism that names power without turning another woman’s suffering into a hook. Share this article, follow SCREAMING IN ALL CAPS through its newsletter and revisit its archive of work on film, television, politics and internet culture. Before pressing play, reward productions that centre context and consent rather than trauma alone.

Ask hosts to explain their sources, correct errors and credit the people whose testimony carries the episode. Choose shows that treat victims as people with rights beyond the case, and challenge racialised framing in advertising, episode titles or recommendation feeds. Better true crime is possible when grief remains a human experience rather than a commodity.