Winnipeg, Canada Subscribe
Another feminist response to pop culture Learn More

Strong Female Character Is Not a Compliment

Reviews run on compressed verdicts, and the fastest one in circulation is "a strong female character." It lands like a conclusion: nod, move on, next film. The phrase appears to say something while doing almost nothing. It names a quality, announces that the quality was noticed, and skips the harder work of explaining who this woman is and what the text asks us to make of her.

The archives of this site, which run from 2013 to 2021, are full of the language popular culture uses to describe itself, and this phrase keeps surfacing in headlines, in studio blurbs, and in the group chats where a show gets cancelled. It began as a defensive boast, a way of insisting that a series deserved to exist. It has since hardened into a way of not reading.

Australian audiences meet the phrase in familiar conditions: a critic in Melbourne or Sydney calls a woman in a streaming series a strong female character, and the label travels untouched through aggregator sites and podcast round-ups, sitting beside local rituals like the flat white bought at a servo drive-through, the footy on the telly, Sunday night with an SBS drama on the ABC. It never asks whether an Australian audience reads strong the way the writer means it.

This is the case against the shortcut. It flatters the reviewer more than the character, rewards a narrow script of female strength, and polices the women who step outside it. Criticism becomes instruction: publish enough pieces using the phrase and audiences learn that the only remarkable woman is the one who fights back, talks over everyone, and never flinches. A feminist publication has no business repeating that lesson.

The Economy of a Two-Word Verdict

Every review format has shortcuts — slow burn, elevated horror, underwritten, sizzling chemistry — and readers still know roughly what they mean. "Strong female character" compresses a judgement about a person, which is a different operation entirely. It sounds evaluative and lands somewhere vague, closer to I noticed she existed and seemed competent.

The phrase also insulates the review from accountability. If the character is thin, the praise pre-empts the objection; if she is cruel and fascinating, the phrase becomes a shield against noticing the cruelty. Either way the reader gets the appearance of feminist attention without the risk that attention normally carries.

That is why it spreads so easily. It flatters the critic, who appears alert to what others missed; it flatters the studio, whose marketing language it echoes; and it costs the reader nothing, because nobody has actually claimed anything falsifiable.

Armour Is Not Agency

Underneath the phrase sits a narrow definition of strength: volume, refusal, physical capability, moral certainty. The woman who interrupts, out-drinks, out-shouts and never apologises matches the template, and the critic reports the match as strength. Anyone powerful in a quieter register gets logged as lacking it.

Melbourne-set drama The Letdown offers a case in point, with Rose Byrne's Frankie, a nurse who holds a chaotic ward together through patience rather than force. Nothing in the performance is loud, and all of it is strong. Calling that not a strong female character reveals that the label measures something other than the character.

There is a familiar pipeline here: strong woman becomes bad girl, and bad girl becomes a woman whose femininity is treated as evidence the writing has gone wrong. The shorthand serves the reader who has already decided what a woman may be allowed to be, and serves the text it claims to describe least of all.

Strength That Depends on Other People

The phrase assumes strength is self-contained, so it cannot see strength that is relational or collective. Much of the strongest characterisation in Australian television is not solitary. Bluey, set in Brisbane and made by Ludo Studio, builds its best material out of repair: apologies, boundaries, restarts, a parent learning to lose an argument with a seven-year-old. Nothing in it is loud. All of it is strong.

Total Control, made for the ABC and set in Canberra, locates strength in an Aboriginal family damaged by policy and prejudice, where the power available to its characters comes from kinship and networks of care. Judy Davis's senator is formidable because of what sustains her, not because she dominates every scene.

Neither series lacks a strong female character. That is precisely the problem: a label built to rate individual heroism registers political, communal and relational strength as nothing at all. A shorthand that cannot see four kinds of strength is not summarising the text. It is filtering it.

What the Shorthand Says and What It Skips

The habit is fixable, and the fix is mostly a matter of length. Reviews are allowed to spend the space a two-word verdict takes up on the work itself.

Shortcut in reviews What it quietly assumes A question that describes more
"A strong female character" Strength equals volume, refusal and force What does she want, and what does she risk to get it?
"She's a bad girl" Female agency reads as moral deviance Whose interests does her behaviour serve?
"Unproblematic" Any conflict with the hero is the writing's fault Who bears the cost of her choices?
"The show needed a female lead" Presence itself counts as achievement What does the text change because she is in it?

The substitutions cost a sentence or two, and that cost is the point. A review exists to describe the thing it reviews, so a phrase that ends the conversation early is a missed opportunity rather than a shortcut. Critics who reach for it are not being concise; they are being opaque.

The Local Machinery Around the Phrase

Australian review culture runs on a small set of institutions — the ABC, SBS, Screen Australia funding, a handful of local production companies — inside a market dominated by Hollywood and streaming. The language of reviews stays porous: a phrase picked up in a Melbourne preview travels into national coverage and back out to the group chat, wearing its original meaning like a borrowed coat.

Legislation sharpens the stakes. New South Wales's Domestic Violence Act 2007 and the coercive control offences built alongside it describe abuse as a pattern of isolation and control rather than a single bad incident, so a review that reduces a controlling woman to a strong female character has misread the very idea of power the law is trying to name. Vague praise also sits oddly beside Australian workplaces, where employers with 100 or more employees must report their gender pay gap to the Fair Work Ombudsman under the Fair Work Act 2009. When equity is measured in dollars, two-word admiration is thin currency.

The market matters for another reason. Australian audiences are often sold female strength as a product, including by studios building campaigns around a woman who does action or sexuality rather than care work, politics or labour. The phrase belongs to that sales language, and it lands hardest in a market that can least afford it, where public-interest drama competes with imported spectacle.

Writing the Way We Want to Read

The alternative is not complicated. Name what the character does rather than how she seems; give her interiority and material circumstances; say whose story the text is really telling and what the writing does with her. She runs a family crisis line in Darwin and handles every caller without raising her voice says more than a strong female character, and it can be argued with.

None of that requires a review to be longer than it wants to be. It requires reviews to be about the work. When the phrase appears, the useful response is to notice what it has swallowed: the behaviour, the stakes, the contradictions, the class and race and sexuality the text either handled or ignored.

Support criticism that does this. Subscribe to the SCREAMING IN ALL CAPS newsletter, send a pitch to the Winnipeg desk, and pass this piece on to the group chat that has been calling every woman with a job a strong female character since 2013. The phrase stays powerful only while it goes unexamined, and criticism that names what it hides is the fastest way to retire it.