Winnipeg, Canada Subscribe
Another feminist response to pop culture Learn More

Let them eat cake and the monstrous rich woman on screen

Every so often, a period drama needs a wealthy woman who is contemptuous of the people beneath her, and the script reaches for the same four words. Let them eat cake. It is a phrase the woman supposedly said, and that everyone knows she never did: Marie Antoinette was five years old and still in Austria when Rousseau published the line in his Confessions in 1785, and the words she actually used at court were "qu'ils mangent de la brioche," a joke about a luxury wheat bread rather than a slice of iced cake. The myth has outlived the history by two centuries.

That longevity is the point. The phrase has become the fastest way to flatten a woman with money into a caricature of moral emptiness, and it arrives in a period when the flattening is useful to institutions rather than to audiences. It lets a story about a starving crowd end with a punchline about a woman's dinner, and it lets a story about a century of colonial extraction finish with a scene of a rich lady being told she has bad manners.

The genre's favourite shape is familiar: the cold countess, the shallow socialite, the spoiled queen who will be humbled by the people she dismissed. Promote her to protagonist and the trope changes clothes rather than disappearing, becoming a way of punishing female ambition — showing that a woman who wants a bigger house, a crown, a share of the family's business is really a monster in waiting.

Australian viewers meet this script in the same imported favourites everyone else watches, and in stories made here: Foxtel's A Place to Call Home, the ABC's The Secret River, and the period pieces that federal screen incentives keep in production. The distance between a Carlton terrace and a palace in Vienna is smaller than it looks, because the phrase travels.

A phrase Marie Antoinette never said

Rousseau's brioche was an expensive loaf made with butter and eggs, not the cake we picture, and the misquote took a long route to stick. The clearest early smear of Marie Antoinette was a pamphlet attributed to her in 1789, Le Pigmeau, a thinly sourced invention that made the Austrian princess into a glutton. By the twentieth century, the line had hardened into shorthand for aristocratic indifference, and screenwriters have been quoting it ever since.

Three prejudices travel inside the phrase. There is class contempt, the assumption that the hungry are silly and must be managed rather than listened to. There is food-shaming, since cake and brioche are the least flattering things a woman can be seen wanting. And there is a racialised image of a foreign, decadent, cruel woman — which is why the phrase attaches to queens and countesses so readily, and why it can be used to dismiss a woman who has done serious work.

The trick is that the line feels like character rather than ideology, which is exactly what makes it so durable. A character who says it can be argued with, corrected, outgrown. A structure that runs on it cannot.

The scripts the trope rewrites

The richest examples are not the villains at all. They are the women who did something with their money, and the shows that refuse to let them.

How the trope shows up on screen:

What the trope buries:

How class contempt gets gendered

Watch how the same behaviour is scored. A male industrialist or landowner in The Gilded Age is called ruthless, driven, understandable in his context. His wife, with the same money and a fraction of the screen time, becomes the snob whose face is meant to signal the audience's sneer. The contempt itself is not a general property of the ruling class; it is a device for making one half of that class unbearable.

The same pattern governs how historical women are dismissed. A queen who is handed bad advice, isolated at court and given no honest counsel gets rewritten as a woman who ate cake while her kingdom suffered. The structural constraint vanishes the moment a phrase is available.

Outside the drama, the meme keeps doing political work. It is the most efficient way to end an argument about inequality by mocking the people making it — the unemployed, the pensioners, the single mothers — and it has been used against the wealthy during the pandemic and the cost-of-living squeeze, which is the period drama of our own household budgets.

Australian echoes of let them eat cake

Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide all carry the names of British aristocrats and officials, while Canberra keeps an Aboriginal name for the country it governs. The joke about ruling from afar therefore lands in a place whose street map commemorates the very people who might have said it. The republic referendum of 1999 kept a wealthy woman at the centre of the constitution, and the Republic Advisory Committee's 2023 report recommending an Australian head of state confirmed how little appetite there is for the argument. Let them eat cake, said the institutions that will not budge.

The 2023 Voice to Parliament referendum offered a local echo of the same condescension: the people most affected by remote services were asked to vote on a body they would not control, and the proposed body was tied to a modest funding envelope rather than legislated by parliament. Alongside it sits the Aged Care Act 2024, which begins operating in November 2025 and reshapes who pays for the care of older women with assets, their families, and the exhausted carers who do the actual work.

Meanwhile the market does the talking. The cash rate climbed past four per cent in late 2023, grocery prices kept climbing under ACCC monitoring, and the ordinary Australian counter has its own version of the line — a meat pie that costs around six dollars at a suburban servo and considerably more in the city, handed over with a flat white in the other hand. Let them eat a meat pie, the meme says, and the arithmetic gets done at the till.

What a feminist retelling would look like

The interesting question is not how a wealthy woman becomes monstrous but what happens if the script refuses the assignment. The Power, the 2021 BBC and Netflix dystopia, tried the reverse, giving women the machinery of power and then discovering that the dystopia still had limits; The Power's feminist failure is a useful account of why the adaptation's future felt thin. Australian readers have their own feminist media infrastructure to argue with and through, from the Voice newspaper to the archives of Winnipeg-based SCREAMING IN ALL CAPS, whose criticism ran from 2013 to 2021.

A feminist period drama would let a rich woman's anger point outward, at the machine rather than the menu. It would let her be wrong about cake and right about bread, show the price of a bad line and the alliances it costs, and refuse the neat humbling that the genre has been serving for a century. The privileged woman is not the villain of the story. Sometimes she is the one who finally has to say what everyone else has been saying.

Start with the archive: read SCREAMING IN ALL CAPS on the shows you have already watched, subscribe to the newsletter for new feminist criticism, and send in your own review of the last period drama that let a rich woman eat cake.